33 sha l l be l i a bl e i n t hi s r e spe c t i n a c c o r da n c e w i t h t he ge ne r a l r ul e s l i a bi l i t y f or m i nor ne g l i g e n c e sha l l be e x c l ude d t o t he e x t e nt not ot he r w i se st i pul a t e d be l ow N on c om pl i a nc e w i t h t he A gr e e m e nt s obl i g a t i o ns w i l l be sub j e c t t o pe n a l t i e s i n t he i n t e r e st of a l l Me m be r s S a nc t i on s c oul d i nc l ude pa y m e nt of f i x e d i nde m ni t i e s de l a y i n pr ovi di ng da t a non c om pl i a n c e w i t h e x c l usi vi t y c l a use s e t c f i na nc i a l c om pe ns a t i on t o of f se t a n y d a m a g e pa y m e nt of i nt e r e st d e l a y i n pa y m e nt s of c ont r i b ut i on t o t he C onsor t i um w or k e x c l usi on f r om t he C ons or t i um i n t he m ost se r i ous c a se s f a i l ur e t o pr ovi de i nf or m a t i on f a i l ur e t o pa y di sc l osur e of a n y c onf i d e nt i a l m a t e r i a l e t c T he sa nc t i ons w i l l be de c i de d upon b y t h e A ss e m bl y i n a pr opor t i ona t e non di sc r i m i na t or y c onsi st e nt a nd dul y j ust i f i e d w a y A Me m be r sha l l not be he l d l i a bl e t o a not he r Me m be r he r e t o f or i ndi r e c t c onse que nt i a l or f i na nc i a l l oss i n c l udi ng l oss of pr o f i t l oss of busi ne ss c ont r a c t s da m a ge of r e put a t i on a r i si ng f r om or i n c onne c t i on w i t h obl i g a t i ons unde r t hi s A gr e e m e nt 2 L i abi l i t y re l at e d t o t he use of St udi e s Me m be r s of t he C onsor t i um a ss um e l i a bi l i t y f or t he c or r e c t ne ss of t he i r s t udi e s pr ovi de d i n a c c or d a nc e w i t h t hi s a gr e e m e nt p r ovi de d t he s a m e ha s b e e n a ss e ss e d a nd a ppr ov e d f o r va l i di t y b y a n y e x t e r na l e x pe r t a ppoi nt e d b y t h e C onsor t i um A Me m be r sha l l not be l i a bl e t o a not he r Me m be r he r e t o f or i ndi r e c t c ons e que nt i a l or f i na nc i a l l oss i nc l udi ng l oss of pr of i t l oss of busi ne ss c ont r a c t s da m a g e of r e put a t i on a r i si n g f r om t he use of i nc or r e c t but b y a n e x t e r na l e x pe r t a ss e ss e d a nd a ppr ove d st udi e s ow ne d b y a not he r Me m b e r of t he C onsor t i u m a s de sc r i be d b y t h e pr e vi ous se nt e nc e O t he r Me m be r s of t he C onsor t i um sha l l not be he l d l i a bl e f or m i s use of I nf o r m a t i on de ve l ope d unde r t he A g r e e m e nt b y on e or m or e Me m be r s E a c h Me m be r i s l i a bl e w i t h r e spe c t t o i t s a c t i vi t i e s a n d obl i g a t i ons out si de t he sc ope a nd t he a c t i vi t i e s of t he C onsor t i um A Me m be r sha l l not be he l d l i a bl e f or m i sus e b y ot h e r M e m be r s of I nf or m a t i on i t m a de a va i l a bl e t o t h e C onsor t i um or de v e l ope d b y t h e C onsor t i um unl e ss t he w i l f ul m i sc onduc t a nd gr oss ne g l i g e nc e of t ha t Me m be r i s a t t he or i gi n of t he m i sus e 3 L i abi l i t y of t he M e m be rs i n re l at i on t o t hi rd par t i e s E a c h Me m b e r t o t hi s A g r e e m e nt sha l l be l i a bl e vi s a vi s t hi r d pa r t i e s c l a i m s a r i si ng sol e l y a nd di r e c t l y f r om o r i n c onn e c t i on w i t h t ha t Me m be r s r e spons i bi l i t y und e r t h i s A gr e e m e nt T he Me m be r s of t he c onsor t i um sha l l suppor t a Me m be r a g a i nst w hom a c l a i m f or l i a bi l i t y a r i si n g